
The home page lists the best of the best, the athletes who stood taller, for longer, among their contemporaries (and, uh, Karl Malone. Sorry, there’s always one …)
But the inevitable question occurs when you reach the end of the list … who’s next? Or maybe it’s, “where are the football players?” The top 20 is dominated by three sports that allow all-rounders to shine. The specialists show up a bit later.
What was interesting was that the 30-point mark became this convenient round number separating the true greats from the rest. Everyone over 30.00 is an unquestioned hall-of-famer. Below that, it can be arguable.
But even in this rarified air, there is a sliding scale. The top 20 have a 5-point spread, from 37.69 to 32.65. The next 2.65 points encompass 47 players. As you go done the list, it keeps getting more crowded.
We’ll actually start with Tris Speaker, in anticipation of the inevitable day when LeBron James bumps him off the front page.
Sport | Games | Total | Per 160 | Rating | |
Tris Speaker | Baseball | 2809 | 279.42 | 15.92 | 32.63 |
Walter Johnson | Baseball | 808 | 177.51 | 19.20 | 32.53 |
Frank Woolley | Cricket | 978 | 129.03 | 21.11 | 32.47 |
Oscar Roberston | Basketball | 1126 | 143.83 | 20.44 | 32.43 |
Allen Iverson | Basketball | 985 | 129.39 | 21.02 | 32.39 |
Garry Sobers | Cricket | 478 | 70.00 | 23.86 | 32.23 |
Honus Wagner | Baseball | 2809 | 274.75 | 15.65 | 32.23 |
Johan Cruijff | Soccer | 618 | 88.12 | 22.81 | 32.20 |
Sammy Baugh | Football | 171 | 28.67 | 26.83 | 32.18 |
Wilfred Rhodes | Cricket | 1110 | 140.88 | 20.31 | 32.18 |
Ted Williams | Baseball | 2299 | 239.37 | 16.66 | 32.13 |
Richard Hadlee | Cricket | 660 | 84.97 | 22.73 | 31.94 |
Wally Hammond | Cricket | 634 | 88.69 | 22.38 | 31.80 |
Eddie Collins | Baseball | 2860 | 270.34 | 15.12 | 31.57 |
Stan Musial | Baseball | 3049 | 281.54 | 14.77 | 31.55 |
Frank Robinson | Baseball | 2843 | 268.77 | 15.13 | 31.52 |
Maurice Tate | Cricket | 679 | 92.74 | 21.85 | 31.48 |
Jim Brown | Football | 122 | 20.46 | 26.83 | 31.36 |
Rogers Hornsby | Baseball | 2271 | 229.76 | 16.19 | 31.35 |
Mickey Mantle | Baseball | 2466 | 242.59 | 15.74 | 31.32 |
Zico | Soccer | 402 | 59.30 | 23.60 | 31.30 |
Gerd Müller | Soccer | 625 | 86.01 | 22.02 | 31.29 |
Hakeem Olajuwon | Basketball | 1383 | 160.80 | 18.60 | 31.28 |
Tim Duncan | Basketball | 1643 | 182.49 | 17.77 | 31.28 |
Steve Van Buren | Football | 87 | 14.89 | 27.38 | 31.24 |
Tich Freeman | Cricket | 592 | 82.05 | 22.18 | 31.23 |
Jerry West | Basketball | 1085 | 132.70 | 19.57 | 31.09 |
Alfredo Di Stéfano | Soccer | 695 | 93.06 | 21.42 | 31.07 |
Nap Lajoie | Baseball | 2480 | 240.67 | 15.53 | 31.04 |
Larry Bird | Basketball | 1061 | 129.90 | 19.59 | 30.99 |
Mel Ott | Baseball | 2745 | 256.29 | 14.94 | 30.95 |
Julius Erving | Basketball | 1432 | 162.74 | 18.18 | 30.94 |
Joe DiMaggio | Baseball | 1787 | 191.11 | 17.11 | 30.94 |
Peyton Manning | Football | 293 | 44.37 | 24.23 | 30.89 |
Kevin Garnett | Basketball | 1605 | 176.41 | 17.59 | 30.87 |
Wayne Gretzky | Hockey | 1788 | 190.32 | 17.03 | 30.83 |
Dan Carter | Rugby Union | 343 | 50.69 | 23.65 | 30.77 |
Don Hutson | Football | 121 | 19.89 | 26.29 | 30.75 |
Newsy Lalonde | Hockey | 316 | 46.87 | 23.73 | 30.58 |
Joe Morgan | Baseball | 2699 | 249.00 | 14.76 | 30.54 |
Elgin Baylor | Basketball | 980 | 119.92 | 19.58 | 30.53 |
Rickey Henderson | Baseball | 3141 | 273.87 | 13.95 | 30.50 |
Gunnar Nordahl | Soccer | 329 | 48.35 | 23.51 | 30.47 |
Lou Gehrig | Baseball | 2198 | 215.25 | 15.67 | 30.34 |
Aubrey Faulkner | Cricket | 118 | 19.04 | 25.82 | 30.18 |
Romário | Soccer | 614 | 81.06 | 21.12 | 30.13 |
Bob Pettit | Basketball | 880 | 108.34 | 19.70 | 30.11 |
Alex Rodriguez | Baseball | 2860 | 252.37 | 14.12 | 30.00 |
A-Rod coming in exactly at the cutoff is right on brand. As promised, it’s a more diverse list, with football, hockey and rugby all getting someone in.
But the questions linger. Where’s Maradona? Magic Johnson? Remember when I said that 30 points was a great cutoff? Well, that’s mostly true, but you should see some of the names in the 29-plus range. They deserve their own posting, coming soon …